A Swimming Pool of Silver Dollars: The Great Silver Dollar Melt of 1918
By: Steve Wolff
Almost anyone with a passing interest in silver dollars has come across a reference to the Pittman Act of 1918. But beyond the dry, historical reference to a bill passed over ninety years ago, lurks something huge. Something that forever changed the face of coin collecting. Something that, to this very day, impacts each and every Morgan Silver Dollar that has survived.
In 1918, Great Britain had a silver problem on its hands. They were in the midst of World War I and needed silver bullion to back millions of British banknotes - particularly in India, where German forces had incited Indian citizens to cash in their notes for actual silver. So, back in Washington D.C., Democratic senator Key Pittman of Nevada stepped forward with a proposal. His bill, called the Pittman Act, was passed on April 22, 1918 and authorized the melting of up to 350 million silver dollars - which would then be sold to Britain for one dollar per ounce of bullion. A total of 270,232, 722 silver dollars were eventually melted under the Pittman Act, which was nearly half of the entire Morgan Silver Dollar mintage struck up to that time.
The 400-Mile Stack
Luckily, another provision of the Act authorized the later minting a replacement dollar for every one melted. This process began in 1921, after the War ended. Because no new silver dollar coin design was approved yet, the Morgan Dollar made one final appearance in 1921, but was replaced by the Peace Dollar in December of that year. While millions of Morgans were struck in 1921 to replace their melted counterparts, the fact remains that over 270 million dates, mintmarks, and varieties from 1878 to 1904 were lost forever to the melting pots in 1918.
It truly boggles the mind to try and comprehend the reality of this literal sea of silver. But to help visualize what was lost in 1918, allow me to paint a few mental pictures:
A Swimming Pool of Silver Dollars
The Pittman Act melt produced over 67, 558 cubic feet of silver bullion. Since an Olympic-sized swimming pool holds 88, 263 cubic feet, the lost silver dollars would fill up over three-quarters of an Olympic swimming pool1!
If all 270,232,722 silver dollars could be stacked on top of each other, the stack would tower over 400 miles into the sky2!
A Skyscraper of Silver
The Empire State Building is 1,463 feet tall. The melted silver dollars could be stacked from the street to the very top of the Empire State to form 1,463 individual stacks. Talk about a massive wall of silver!
If silver dollars were laid out to cover a regulation football field, it would take 3,072,000 dollars to make one layer covering the field from end zone to end zone. This means that all the melted Pittman Act silver dollars could completely cover a football field over 87 layers deep3!
Walk from NYC to LA on a Carpet of Silver Dollars
If all the melted silver dollars were laid end-to-end to form a chain, it would stretch from New York City to Los Angles over 2.5 times4.
Protecting our Nation's Border
If the whole cross-country, "Route 66" approach isn't your thing, how about this: That same silver dollar chain, stretching 6,398 miles, could be laid along the borders of the entire USA and would encircle 84% of the entire country5!
The Melting Didn't Stop in 1918
As staggering as these visualizations are, the tragic reality is that many more government and private silver dollar meltings have occurred in the ninety four years since 1918. Millions more were melted during the great run-up in silver prices during the 1980's, and further private meltings continue to this very day. While it is impossible to confirm the exact number of vintage silver that have survived, the renowned coin expert and author, Q. David Bowers has estimated that only 15% or less of all the U.S. silver dollars ever minted have survived to this day6.
About Steve Wolff - Steve Wolff has been involved with collectibles and coins for over 30 years. During that time, Steve has served as a fine art gallery director, president of a nationwide collectible coin company, director of coin product development, liaison with world mints, and his present role as Vice President of Product Development for GovMint.com and its affiliated companies.
**1,000,000 silver dollars = 250 cubic feet (based on Fort Knox estimates conducted by the U.S. Treasury.) The Pittman melt converts to 67,558 cubic feet. An Olympic-sized pool hold 88,263 cubic feet in volume.
- Each silver dollar is .09449 inches thick, so the total stack would be 2,127,857 feet, or 403 miles high.
- Regulation football field is 160' x 300'. 1,280 dollars x 2,400 dollars = 3,072,000 per layer. 87.97 layers total.
- Coin diameter = 1.5". 405,349,083 inches = 6,398 miles. NYC to LA = 2448 miles. (2.614 times)
- Perimeter of USA: 7,610 miles. (.8407 times)
- Q. David Bowers, www.pcgs.com