Circulated vs. Uncirculated Coins. Which should I buy?

What is the difference between circulated and uncirculated coins?

The main difference between the two types of coins can usually be easily identified, and the value difference can often be considerable. Every coin starts its life as uncirculated when it is struck at the mint, and it remains in uncirculated condition until it enters the commerce stream or is otherwise damaged.

Uncirculated Coins

In order to be certified as uncirculated, like these uncirculated U.S coins, a coin must not exhibit any trace of having been in circulation. There are two major factors that indicate a coin is in uncirculated condition:

• Mint luster. Coins that have never been in circulation usually exhibit a distinctive sheen or luster. The luster wears off very quickly once the coin is in circulation and has been touched by bare hands. It may also diminish over time.
• No trace of wear. One of the most obvious signs that a coin is uncirculated is the absence of wear or rubbing on the coin’s high points. As soon as the coin enters circulation, the high points start to show traces of depreciation.

What are the different grades for uncirculated coins?

Uncirculated coins are graded between MS60 and MS70. A coin in perfect MS70 condition will not have any contact marks or other blemishes, while a coin in MS60 condition may show contact marks and may be missing much of its luster.

What Are Proof Coins?

Proof coins, like Proof American Silver Eagles for example, are not intended to be introduced into circulation but are made only for the collector market. While regular coins are struck just once under normal pressure and at a high rate of speed, each Proof coin is carefully struck at least twice under high pressure to bring out the full details of the design. The background of a Proof coin is usually mirror-like and considered to be the “best of the best.” Unless they are mishandled or placed into circulation, Proof coins will be uncirculated and are graded only between PF60 and PF70. The same standards exist for determining their grade as for regular uncirculated coins.

Circulated Coins

Any coin that has entered circulation is classified as circulated. The condition of a circulated coin ranges from barely-perceptible traces of wear to so heavily worn that few details can still be seen. Some coins are collected almost exclusively in uncirculated condition, while others are virtually unobtainable in uncirculated condition. In general, the older the coin, the more difficult it can be to find in uncirculated condition. Modern coins are usually collected only in uncirculated condition.

To illustrate the potential difference between the value of circulated and uncirculated coins, look at the 1884 Morgan Silver Dollar from the San Francisco mint. The value of this coin is about $50 in the average circulated grade of EF40. Its value increases to about $5,500 in the lowest uncirculated grade of MS60 and $250,000 in the high grade of MS65.